To the editor,
During a recent visit to International Falls, DFL U.S. Senate candidate Al Franken sought to dramatically reinvent himself. Given his long history of extreme and nasty name calling, I would advise all readers of this newspaper to be very wary of Franken’s election year rhetoric.
To be sure, the kind of ugly attacks politics long practiced by Franken are without precedent in Minnesota political history. As chairman of the Republican Party of Minnesota and a long-time participant in the traditional give and take of politics, I can say with certainty that we have never seen anything like this before.
For years, Franken has made millions attacking those with whom he disagrees in unusually harsh language. He has lashed out at Republicans as “shameless (expletive deleted),” “right-wing mother(expletive deleted),” and repeatedly joked about the hypothetical murder and execution of members of the current administration. Franken has also demeaned former U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft as "something of a nutcase" and savaged a presidential advisor as “human filth.”
While Franken continues trying to reinvent himself this year with millions of dollars in television ads funded largely by out of state contributors, even prominent Democrats have taken notice of his mean streak. Democrat Mike Ciresi has noted that “Al Franken has made a living calling people names.”
Franken’s stridency and caustic rhetoric is hardly new. During the Clinton administration, Franken managed to offend then Vice President Al Gore at a Washington dinner by joking about the menstrual cycle of Newt Gingrich’s teenaged daughter.
True to form, Franken has continued to personally attack his political opponents during his campaign for U.S. Senate. During a visit to Northfield’s Carleton College, the Star Tribune reported that Franken mocked a conservative student over his manner of speaking and nervous habits. Most damning for Franken was the fact that the conservative college student’s account was verified by the president of the Carleton College Democrats.
In spite of all the attacks from Franken, a brief review demonstrates that Sen. Norm Coleman has been a real leader for our state. To cite just a few examples:
• Sen. Coleman led passage of a bill to provide travel reimbursement for our brave men and women on leave from Iraq and Afghanistan.
• Sen. Coleman led the passage of a bill requiring the Department of Veterans Affairs to develop a new program to help veterans receive all the benefits they are entitled to.
• Sen. Coleman delivered emergency disaster assistance to help farmers hard hit by natural disasters.
• Sen. Coleman has been a leader in securing increased Pell Grants to help students attend college.
While Senator Coleman has been a real leader for our state, Al Franken has repeatedly demonstrated that he fundamentally lacks the experience, judgment and maturity necessary for the U.S. Senate. No matter how many millions Franken spends on slick and misleading television ads, I am confident Minnesotans will reject his extreme attack politics.
Ron Carey,
chairman of the Republican Party of Minnesota,
St. Paul, MN

Okay, so if there is anyone...
Back to page topOkay, so if there is anyone out there who doesn't know what Al Franken is about, read the news once in a while. The Franken campaign has done nothing to hide his history and his take on any situation. He is the way he is! Get a grip!
What we need is a leader who doesn't have the same "experience" that Norm Coleman does. We need someone who is fresh and knows what needs to be changed.
Minnesota has a history of political experimentation. Look at Jesse Ventura. Didn't work out how everyone wanted, but you never know until you try.
I found this letter to the editor slightly amusing, since it really shows how worried the Coleman campaign is when they start accusing DFL candidates of being what they obviously have always been.
It is so sad that Mr. Carey...
Back to page topIt is so sad that Mr. Carey was born without a sense of humor. He must be very boring to hang out with. It is also very sad that he resorts to personal attacks on Mr. Franken. I think that says a lot about Sen. Coleman. Carey is already in panic mode before the DFL has even selected a candidate. He will have to learn to live with Franken's sense of humor much like the rest of us have learned to live with Coleman's lack of same.
Republican party leader Ron...
Back to page topRepublican party leader Ron Carey claims Minnesota has never seen anything so awful as Al Franken in our past politics---although his criticisms, slanted as they are, nearly ALL refer to Mr. Franken's statements from years ago, long before Franken had any intention or interest in running for office himself. Had Franken, like Norm Coleman, spent his life on the public payroll, he'd probably have acquired a professional politician's talent for telling people what they want to hear.
I also must fault Mr. Carey for his selective memory or perhaps simple ignorance of Minnesota political history. Has he even forgotten the recent history of dirty campaigns, like Republican Arne Carlson's amazing comeback after the mysterious swimming-pool scandal allegations against Jon Grunseth, the Republican-endorsed candidate for Governor, about 20 years ago? Or what about Republican Rod Grams' bare-knuckle bludgeoning of Ann Wynia in 1994, or her campaign's sloppy attempts to slime back?
Not as offensive to public sensibilities, but worth mentioning, is the 1962 campaign by Karl Rolvaag's supporters to smear Governor Elmer Anderson over a phony accusation about Interstate 35; documented for historians by Thomas Roeser in his book "Ingenious Deceit: The Story of a Scandal That Never Existed."
What Mr. Carey doesn't know about Minnesota's history is that it has witnessed political campaigns easily as dirty and treacherous as the stuff Carey's buddy Karl Rove dreams up.
The very first election for Governor of Minnesota was won by Henry Sibley's ballot-box stuffing (316-to-0) in Pembina---the last precinct to report.
A long litany of abuses and corruption attended our state's history under Republican domination in the "Gilded Age" of the late 19th century. And the 1918 Republican primary election for Governor saw the Non-partisan League's candidate, C. A. Lindbergh, assailed as disloyal to America, despite his record as a five-term Republican congressman. Lindbergh was denied the right to hold political rallies in some towns; his supporters--and the candidate himself--were arrested for attempting to campaign, and Lindbergh was literally shot at while leaving a campaign stop.
That was the length the Republican establishment went to ninety years ago to sustain its political control.
But ruthless political combat reached a pinnacle during the Roaring 20's prohibition era and the Great Depression which followed. Republican lawyer Thomas Schall defeated incumbent Farmer-Labor party senator Magnus Johnson in 1924, but Schall's seating was delayed for 21 months while the Senate investigated his alleged shakedown of Minneapolis bootleggers for campaign contributions. When he was finally seated, after diverting blame to his campaign manager, portion's of Schall's first speech in the Senate were stricken from the record because of "his highly seasoned remarks." That's one of yours, Mr. Carey.
As historian John Beecher tells it, for the Republican primary in 1930, Schall "landed on the unwary [Governor] Christiansen with his brass knuckles flailing and his copper-toed boots savagely kicking his opponent's groin. No lie was too fantastic and no charge too vicious if the slightest veil of plausibility coud be drawn over it." Schall won re-election.
In the depth of the Depression, Minnesota's Farmer-Labor Party elected its first Governor---the legendary Floyd B. Olson. Olson's Republican opponents took the low road against him, distributing a pamphlet "presenting Olson as a confederate of crooked cops and prostitutes." Olson won in 1930, and dominated state politics until his death from cancer, while yet a young man, in 1936.
His Farmer-Labor successor, Elmer Benson, was beaten by the Republicans, after a campaign marked by GOP harping on the charge of Jewish and communist control of the Benson administration. The anti-Semitic slurs of the 1938 campaign have been documented by Minnesota's dean of historians, Hyman Berman. That's another one for your side, Mr. Carey.
Many more examples could be given. I suggest that Mr. Carey "doth protest too much." If all politicians who used the vocabulary which Mr. Carey seems to find so shocking, were disqualified from seeking public office, we'd have many vacancies.
Should Mr. Franken revert to vulgar language in the course of this campaign, Mr. Carey still needs to tread cautiously. The Republican Party is the host to the political parasites like Ann Coulter, Bill O'Reilly, Rush Limbaugh, and other spewers of vitriol---even a local Minnesota radio personality who said in the last campaign that he'd "like to see Wellstone dead"---and whose support Mr. Coleman did not repudiate even after the tragic plane crash killed Senator Wellstone, his wife and daughter, and five others.
That was the same year when Republicans in other states also hit new lows. A service-dodging Republican candidate in Georgia beat triple-amputee Vietnam combat vet Max Cleland by running commercials showing Cleland as a sympathizer of Osama bin Laden.
Mr. Carey, Senator Coleman, and their clique are angry at Al Franken.
Here's why---the path that brought Franken from entertainment into politics began with Franken's determination to confront and expose the lies and smears so effectively used in the past by the worst (and now dominant) elements of the Republican party. Coleman went right along with the Libel League when their tide was rising---now the Senator is desperate to pretend that he suddenly nothing but a baby-faced innocent victim.